Junior asks his dad why they celebrate thanksgiving. what does his dad say in response?

Advertisement - Guide continues below

Previous Next

Chapter 14

Thanksgiving

  • Thanksgiving comes and the Spirit family celebrates with a turkey and all the trimmings. Junior wonders why Indians even celebrate Thanksgiving. His Dad says they should be thankful that the white men didn't kill all of the Indians. Everyone laughs. (Gallows humor.)
  • Junior misses Rowdy coming over to eat pumpkin pie, so he draws a picture of the two of them together (fig 14.1) and goes to Rowdy's house to deliver it to him.
  • Rowdy's father says that Rowdy isn't home (he is), so Junior asks him to give Rowdy the drawing. Rowdy's father says that Junior is "kind of gay," but that he'll give him the picture (14.19). (Harsh.)
  • Walking away, Junior stops at the end of the driveway and sees Rowdy watching him from his bedroom window.
  • Junior calls to him, but Rowdy flips Junior off and walks away from the window. He's glad that Rowdy at least didn't rip up the drawing. That's something.

Previous Next

More on The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian Navigation

Tired of ads?

Join today and never see them again.

Junior enjoys Thanksgiving with his mom, dad, and grandmother, but misses Rowdy because he always used to come over for a pumpkin-pie eating contest with Junior. Junior draws a cartoon of the two of them “like we used to be”—as a pair of superheroes with matching costumes, bumping fists—and brings it to Rowdy’s house.

Junior’s cartoon shows him and Rowdy not only as a team, but also as superheroes. Rowdy isn’t purely an advocate for “bone-crushing reality”—in fact, the friendship in which nothing seemed insurmountable as long as Rowdy and Junior were friends was just another shared dream world, one that Junior gave up for a more practical pursuit of his ambitions.

Rowdy’s dad answers the door and says Rowdy isn’t home. He looks at Junior’s cartoon and calls it “kind of gay,” but promises to give it to Rowdy. Junior wants to curse at Rowdy’s dad and tell him he thinks he is being courageous in trying to fix their friendship, but refrains from saying anything.

Junior chooses to tolerate Rowdy’s dad’s comments rather than fight back openly and express his true feelings. This is strategically necessary to make sure Rowdy’s dad delivers the message, so in some ways it shows Junior’s maturity and judgment, but it is also another example of how “reservation Junior”—the “human target” who never fights back—is still unable to stand up for himself.

As he walks away from the house, Junior sees Rowdy holding the cartoon and watching him sadly from an upstairs window. When Junior waves, Rowdy flips him off, but Junior is happy that at least Rowdy hasn’t ripped up his cartoon: it means that Rowdy must still respect him a little.

Junior feels his cartoons are an extension of himself. Rowdy’s choice not to take his revenge out on the cartoon suggest that he feels the same way, although he arguably respects the cartoon more than Junior himself, since it shows a dream of Rowdy’s as well. Despite the middle finger, this interaction still seems like a sign of respect and caring for Junior—one of the many contradictory aspects of Rowdy and Junior’s friendship.

Recommended textbook solutions

Edge Reading, Writing and Language: Level C

David W. Moore, Deborah Short, Michael W. Smith

304 solutions

Literature and Composition: Reading, Writing,Thinking

1st EditionCarol Jago, Lawrence Scanlon, Renee H. Shea, Robin Dissin Aufses

1,697 solutions

Technical Writing for Success

3rd EditionDarlene Smith-Worthington, Sue Jefferson

468 solutions

The Language of Composition: Reading, Writing, Rhetoric

2nd EditionLawrence Scanlon, Renee H. Shea, Robin Dissin Aufses

661 solutions

When discussing Thanksgiving what does Junior's dad say they should be thankful for?

His Dad says they should be thankful that the white men didn't kill all of the Indians. Everyone laughs. (Gallows humor.) Junior misses Rowdy coming over to eat pumpkin pie, so he draws a picture of the two of them together (fig 14.1) and goes to Rowdy's house to deliver it to him.

What is Junior's dad's response when Junior asks him in Chapter 14 Thanksgiving What do Indians have to be thankful for?

What is Junior's dad's response when Junior asks him in Chapter 14: "Thanksgiving," "What do Indians have to be thankful for?" We should give thanks that no one lives forever.

What is Junior's opinion of Thanksgiving Why?

What is Junior's opinion on Thanksgiving? Why? He thinks it's funny that Indians celebrate thanksgiving considering right after the Indians and Pilgrims were friends, the Pilgrims started shooting at them. He believes there's nothing Indians should be thankful for.

What advice does Junior's dad give him about trying out for the team?

Junior's dad tells Junior the story as a way to say he should “dream big to get big.” Junior should try out for the Reardan basketball team.

Toplist

Última postagem

Tag